Different Perks for Different Employees
Print this Article | Send to Colleague
Answer
It is a general best practice to offer perks and apply policies consistently to similarly situated employees to avoid claims of discrimination and unfair treatment. That said, absent a contract to the contrary, employers can generally offer different perks to employees who work in different capacities (for example, executive versus nonexecutive), so long as the criteria for doing so are not unlawfully discriminatory and comply with applicable law. Giving some employees (or even just one) a more attractive vacation package and not providing the same to others is a form of discrimination, but it is not unlawful discrimination unless the basis for excluding others is membership in a protected class.
However, even if this kind of discrimination is not expressly unlawful, there can be significant issues associated with providing certain employees (or just one) with enhanced perks. Those who do not enjoy the perks may resent the employer for the differentiation, and this can lower morale and have consequences for employee relations. Additionally, even though an employer’s policy may appear neutral on its face, if it has a disproportionate effect upon a protected class of workers, there may be exposure to discrimination claims on a theory of disparate impact.
A claim in such a scenario may be able to be defended with evidence of legitimate, nondiscriminatory reasons for an exception (for example, sometimes employers need to provide enhanced vacation perks to attract or retain talent). That said, employee relations and potential discrimination risks exist even if the facts do not legally support such a claim. In other words, while an employer is generally within its rights to establish different policies or provide an enhanced perk along neutral and legitimate lines, doing so may not necessarily be the best practice if there will be employee relations backlash as a result. Generally, it is best practice to have uniformity and consistency in company policies and perks.
